The Most Unique Places To Stay In Gettysburg In 2024

If want to explore some of the most unique places to stay in Gettysburg, I have you covered. As a long-time Gettysburg resident and frequent traveler, I love the wide range of historic and unique accommodations that are available in my own hometown.

From historic houses that witnessed the Battle of Gettysburg, to cozy retreats in the country with their own indoor pool, I have curated a list of the absolute best vacation rentals in Gettysburg for any style or taste.

Each of these unique places to stay in Gettysburg has a story to tell that serves as a touchstone to our past. You won’t just be visiting history in Gettysburg. You can actually stay where it happened!

I’ve included a wide range of price points for every type of traveler. Let’s go!

Don’t Want To Read Until The End?
Historic In Town
: Thaddeus Stevens House $240/nt
Biggest Splurge: The Big House (Indoor Pool) $781/nt
Wallet-Friendly Country Retreat: Airstream $158/nt

NEW ADDITION: Now you can rent a house on the Gettysburg Battlefield that stood during the Battle of Gettysburg.

1. Thaddeus Stevens Log House

I’ll start with one of the oldest and most historic unique places to stay in Gettysburg: the Thaddeus Stevens Log House.

Built in 1790, this log home is straight out of a history book, with original wood floors, walls and beams.

Once owned by Thaddeus Stevens and a five minute walk from downtown Gettysburg, the house sits on land that was occupied by Confederates during the Battle of Gettysburg.

The Thaddeus Stevens house is a log house with yellow door and window frames, and one of the most unique places to stay in Gettysburg.

Even though this house has plenty of historical character, it also contains modern conveniences like central air conditioning, recessed lighting, and fully updated kitchen and baths.

The Thaddeus Steven’s house has 3 bedrooms (2 queen and 1 full), as well as 1 & 1/2 bathrooms.

If you enjoy history, this one of the most unique places to stay in Gettysburg.

$240/average night
Rating: 9.8/134 reviews

2. The Garlach House

Another old pre-Civil War house in Gettysburg with lots of history is The Garlach House. Built in 1830 and a witness to the Battle of Gettysburg, the house sits on Baltimore Street so is convenient to museums, restaurants and shopping.

(It is conveniently located along the route of the annual Remembrance Day Parade and is in the center of activities for the Gettysburg Christmas Festival).

The Garlach House is a unique house available for rent in Gettsysburg. It's a brick house with a yellow and green door and yellow window trim.

This house features a private fenced in backyard where you can enjoy your morning cup of coffee or a glass of wine in the evening. In addition to the Battlefield, it is close to local wineries, golf courses and Liberty Mountain ski resort, as well as lots of museums.

Graphic for Gettysburg handbook, which is blue, showing the cover of the book and reasons to read it. A red buy now button at the bottom.

During the Battle of Gettysburg, Catherine Garlach provided food and water to the Union General, Alexander Schimmelfennig when his horse was shot out from under him in the alley behind the home. He hid in the backyard of the Garlach home in their woodshed while the surrounding streets were occupied by Confederates.

This house has a fully equipped kitchen, 3 bedrooms, full bath, half bath (on the first floor), office, living & dining room along with a laundry/mud room.

This unique place to stay in Gettysburg has a dedicated parking space in the rear for a large truck/SUV and free parking just a short distance away.

$203/average night
Rating: 10.0/11 reviews

3. York Street Manor

The York Street Manor is a unique high-end rental home on York Street in Gettysburg is circa 1839. Located two blocks From Lincoln Square, this historic vacation getaway is tailored for discriminating guests who are looking for an authentic Gettysburg experience.

The house stood as a brick sentinel in the path of retreating Union soldiers on July 1, 1863 and Confederate troops camped in the yard while Confederate General Ewell planned his strategy to take Culp’s Hill.

The York Street Manor in Gettysburg is a two-story white house with black shutters and a red door.

The York Street Manor was where Cecilia Codori and her husband Joseph called home from 1850 to 1865. In 1865, the house was owned by Civil War veteran William F. Baker, Company E of the 87th Pennsylvania Volunteers.

Memoirs of a 16 year old girl who lived across the street (Liberty Hollinger) recalled she and her father yelling at the Confederate soldiers looting the unoccupied homes across from her’s, and how General Robert E. Lee himself and his command paused their horses in front of these houses, surveying their strength.

Nestled only two blocks from the heart of downtown Gettysburg’s Lincoln Square, this unique Gettysburg rental puts you close to Gettysburg tours and lots of free things to do in Gettysburg.

Once you book a unique place to stay in Gettysburg, you’ll want to dine in a unique historic restaurant. Choose from pubs, breweries and fine dining!

The accommodations include three bedrooms, each with its own on-suite bath. The house features two master suites, one with a king bed and one with a queen and full parlor/sitting room.

You can relax on the 2nd floor screened in porch, or enjoy your favorite drink on the back yard porch. Bring your own wine and keep it that perfect temperature in the wine chiller located in the separate media room.

Off-street parking is convenient in the three bay garage which sits on the same location as the original carriage barn along Race Horse Alley.

$414/average night
Rating: 10.0/56 reviews

4. LaVerne Private Guest House

This is definitely one of the most unique places to stay in Gettysburg, and is no ordinary Gettysburg Address.

Built in the 1840’s and newly renovated, this 2-level, 4-bedroom Italianate-style townhome apartment reflects the Federal majesty of the mid-1800’s.

The LaVerne Private Guesthouse has a sign hanging out front of an old dark wood door and brick archway.

Stained glass windows and a chandelier-adorned spa bath are a few of the features of this unique place to stay in Gettysburg.

Located one-half block from Lincoln Square and three doors down from the historic Wills House, The LaVerne is within walking distance to dining, antiquing, shopping, and the theater.

$295/average night
Rating: 9.8/169 reviews

5. The Big House: Splurge With An Indoor Pool

Want to splurge and enjoy your visit to Gettysburg no matter the weather? “The Big House” at Apple Blossom Farm might be the answer to your prayers.

An a-frame house in the center with a long addition on the side and lots of windows.

It is the only Gettysburg rental in the area that offers a year-round heated indoor pool. Located in Gettysburg’s wine and orchard country, the house is back half-mile driveway that is adorned with organic apple trees and friendly deer. (And only a 10-minute drive from downtown Gettysburg).

Relax and spread out in in a two story 3,800 square-foot home on 30 acres. Every one of the 6 bedrooms has been newly decorated with luxury bedding.

Book an American Brew Tour in Gettysburg!

The pool room hosts a dry bar, spiral stairwell to the upstairs great room, picnic table, pool floats and toys, and many more pleasantries.

The outside upper deck has tons of seating and a hammock to enjoy spending time anytime of the day with your friend or family. Wake up and have a cup of joe while overlooking the horse pasture and the start of your beautiful day.

The indoor pool at the Big House with wooden walls and lots of windows.

As if the pool isn’t enough, there is a Family Room downstairs with magnetic darts, foosball, ping pong, air hockey, card table, karaoke machine, and pool table.

The front porch of this Gettysburg rental has a propane grill, and there are plenty of rescue animals to pet on the farm.

$781/average night
Rating: 10.0/181 reviews

6. Airstream In The Country (Hot Tub Optional)

Why stay in a hotel room when you can relax in your own oasis, surrounded by nature in this Airstream? By the way, this is not “roughing it.” With 600-thread-count linens and Egyptian cotton bath sheets, you will have all the comforts of a fine boutique hotel.

The Serenity Airstream is a very unique Gettysburg rental that has a private master suite and a fully equipped kitchen that includes dishes, utensils, and cookware.

A country setting in Gettysburg with an Airstream and picnic area with firepit and round covered lounge area.

The private bath has a separate shower and the entire coach is fully air-conditioned and heated. For outdoor enjoyment, there is a table and chairs, as well as a propane grill and fire pit.

Hot tub, which is located under a private gazebo beside the Airstream starts at an extra $50/night.

Cost $158/average night
Rating: 10.0/58 reviews

7. Pickett Cottage at Briarfield

This is definitely one of the most unique places to stay in Gettysburg, and it’s cozy, quiet and not hard on the wallet!

It’s only about 400 square feet, but that’s the size of a hotel room, and you have a peaceful country setting all to yourself!

The Pickett House at Briarfield is a small brick cabin and is one of the most unique places to stay in Gettysburg.

This country cottage is on a 17-acre private property three miles from the Gettysburg Battlefield and four miles from downtown Gettysburg.

The cottage features a screened porch to enjoy solitude for everything from your morning coffee to your evening cocktail or wine.

$128/average night
Ratings: 10.0/330 reviews

Bonus: Unique Places To Stay In Gettysburg

Want To Stay In A School House?

If you’re looking for peace and quiet outside of town, School House is located just 6 miles from the square in Gettysburg, and even less to Devils Den, Big Round top, the Visitors Center and the Outlet Shoppes of Gettysburg.

An old Amish schoohoulse that is now one of the unusual places to stay in Gettysburg. It is a white cement building with five windows and a small steeple on top.

Once an Amish school house, it has been renovated to include all the comforts of home. Completely surrounded by farm land, you can be sure to enjoy peaceful and quiet evenings.

$141/average night

Historic Hance Hamilton’s House

I had to list this as one of the most unique places to stay in Gettysburg because it was the home of Hance Hamilton in the 1740s, a well known local historical figure. It is 3,000 square feet on more than 2 acres.

Additional history of this unusual places to stay in Gettysburg is that it was occupied by Confederate Major General Robert E. Rodes and his division during the battle of Gettysburg and was used as a summer home by 1930’s Broadway star and Hollywood actor Oscar Shaw.

$350/average night
Rating 8.6/13 reviews

A graphic for Past Lane Travels newsletter sign up that is a burnt red showing a red covered bridge and Sign Up button.

Planning A Trip To Gettysburg

If you’re planning your first trip to Gettysburg (or your 50th), make sure you pick up a copy of the Gettysburg Handbook. It’s got lots of insider tips about places to visit and where the locals go, as does the Gettysburg Bucket List.

If you’re planning a getaway with a special someone, there are lots of romantic things to do in Gettysburg. If you’d rather explore the supernatural, you’ll find many haunted places you can investigate on your own, or Gettysburg ghost tours run all year long.

There are a lot of unique places to stay in Gettysburg that cater to different tastes and preferences. Whether you’re a history enthusiast seeking to immerse yourself in the past, or a traveler looking for modern comforts like an indoor swimming pool, Gettysburg has something special for everyone.

These distinctive lodging options not only provide a comfortable stay, but also enrich your visit to this iconic landmark town.

More Unique Places To Stay In Gettysburg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *